What To Know
- The D5100 has a wider dynamic range than the D200, meaning it can capture more detail in both highlights and shadows.
- It is a good choice for photographers who need a camera that can handle fast-moving subjects and who prefer a larger body and viewfinder.
- The Nikon D5100 is a more compact and affordable camera with a higher resolution sensor, better image quality at high ISOs, and a wider dynamic range.
The Nikon D200 and D5100 are two popular DSLR cameras that have been widely used by photographers of all levels. Both cameras offer a range of features, but they differ in several key areas. In this comprehensive comparison, we will delve into the nuances of each camera to help you make an informed decision about which one is right for your needs.
Image Quality
Sensor: The D200 features a 10.2MP CCD sensor, while the D5100 has a 16.2MP CMOS sensor. CMOS sensors generally offer better image quality at high ISOs, so the D5100 has an edge in this regard.
Dynamic Range: The D5100 has a wider dynamic range than the D200, meaning it can capture more detail in both highlights and shadows. This is especially beneficial for landscape and HDR photography.
Color Depth: Both cameras offer 12-bit color depth, which provides a wide range of colors and smooth tonal transitions.
Performance
Autofocus: The D200 has a more robust autofocus system with 11 focus points, while the D5100 has 11 focus points. The D200 also offers faster autofocus speeds, making it better suited for capturing fast-moving subjects.
Burst Mode: The D200 can shoot up to 5 frames per second (fps), while the D5100 can shoot up to 4 fps. This difference may not be significant for most photographers, but it can be crucial for sports or wildlife photography.
Buffer Size: The D200 has a larger buffer size than the D5100, allowing you to shoot more consecutive frames before the camera slows down.
Ergonomics
Body: The D200 has a larger and heavier body than the D5100, making it less portable. However, the larger size also provides a more comfortable grip and more space for buttons and dials.
LCD Screen: The D5100 has a larger LCD screen (3.0 inches) than the D200 (2.5 inches). The D5100’s screen is also fully articulated, allowing you to shoot from various angles.
Viewfinder: The D200 has a larger and brighter optical viewfinder than the D5100. This is an advantage for photographers who prefer to use the viewfinder for composition and focusing.
Features
Built-in Flash: The D200 has a built-in flash, while the D5100 does not. This can be a useful feature for those who frequently shoot in low-light conditions.
Video Recording: The D5100 offers video recording capabilities, while the D200 does not. This is a significant advantage for those who want to use their camera for video production.
Wireless Connectivity: The D5100 offers built-in Wi-Fi and GPS, while the D200 does not. These features allow you to easily share your images and track your location data.
Price and Availability
The Nikon D200 was discontinued in 2008, while the D5100 was discontinued in 2013. Both cameras are still available on the used market, but prices will vary depending on the condition and accessories included.
Recommendation
The Nikon D200 is a robust and reliable camera with excellent ergonomics and autofocus performance. It is a good choice for photographers who need a camera that can handle fast-moving subjects and who prefer a larger body and viewfinder.
The Nikon D5100 is a more compact and affordable camera with a higher resolution sensor, better image quality at high ISOs, and a wider dynamic range. It is also a good choice for photographers who want a camera with built-in video recording and wireless connectivity.
Top Questions Asked
Q: Which camera has better image quality?
A: The Nikon D5100 has better image quality at high ISOs and a wider dynamic range than the D200.
Q: Which camera has faster autofocus?
A: The Nikon D200 has a faster autofocus system with 11 focus points and faster autofocus speeds.
Q: Which camera is better for video recording?
A: The Nikon D5100 offers built-in video recording capabilities, while the D200 does not.
Q: Which camera is more portable?
A: The Nikon D5100 is more compact and lightweight than the D200, making it more portable.
Q: Which camera has built-in wireless connectivity?
A: The Nikon D5100 offers built-in Wi-Fi and GPS, while the D200 does not.
